Skip to Content

10 Places With Ponies For Sale In Ohio

Looking to buy a pony in Ohio (OH)? 

Finding a reputable and trustworthy pony breeder can sometimes be difficult, but there are plenty of options in the state, so you should be able to find your next animal with ease. To select the best pony and ensure that it is in good condition, make sure to visit the breeders, ranches, or farms in person (if possible). 

Here’s the list of top breeders registered in the state of Ohio that are selling ponies to help you find the best filly, stallion, or foal, depending on your needs and the offer.

Pony Breeders in Ohio

Breeder NameLocationContact NumberWebsite
Whittling Ridge Apple Creek, OH276-429-2142
Amigo Acres Canine & Equine Dundee, OH330-600-8633 or
Green Creek Pony Farm Green Springs,
Windy Hill Farm Millersburg, OH330-231-7500
TopGun Farm Berea, OH440-346-2958
Greymeadows Farm Cutler, OH740-551-9440
The Willows Welsh Ponies West Mansfield,
Stargazey Farms Jackson, OH
Hickory Run Farms Alexandria,
Double R Farms  Mount Sterling,

1. Whittling Ridge 

Ponies On A Field

This pony breeder is located in Apple Creek, Ohio. Whittling Ridge is a two-family operation that focuses on raising good ponies and horses (both in Ohio and Virginia). 

Their animals are accustomed to being ridden or driven on the main roads. This breeder sells small (under 12 hands) and large ponies (over 12 hands) – they have videos of their available animals on their website.

2. Amigo Acres Canine & Equine 

  • Address: Dundee, Ohio 44624
  • Phone: 330-600-8633 or 330-275-9042
  • Email: Contact Form
  • Website:
  • Social Media: n/a
  • Price: More information available with inquiry

Amigo Acres Canine and Equine is a family-owned farm located in Dundee. Together with puppies, this breeder also raises and sells ponies and horses. At their farm, they have several different breeds and types of horses for various uses, from riding and driving to pulling and more. 

Amigo Acres exposes their horses to many different things, from going down the trail over the hills and through the water to driving and riding on the road and meeting all sorts of traffic. 

Check their website’s Horses And Foal page to find currently available and previously sold animals and contact them directly with questions about their foals.

3. Green Creek Pony Farm

This pony breeder is located in Green Springs, OH. Green Creek Farm raises and sells American Shetland Ponies (Classic and Foundation). Their animals are registered with American Miniature Horse Registry (AMHR) and American Shetland Pony Club (ASPC). 

Visit their Facebook page for news and updates on their ponies and contact them directly about the available animals.

4. Windy Hill Farm 

Located in Millersburg, OH, Windy Hill Farm specializes in raising and selling horses and ponies. According to their website, they have one of the largest selections of safe, usable horses and ponies in the USA. Windy Hill Farm also accepts payments via PayPal – contact them for a list of available ponies.

5. Top Gun Farm 

Top Gun Farm is a small farm in Olmsted Township, OH, near Cleveland Hopkins Airport. They focus on raising and selling Welsh ponies. Although they are not a boarding facility, they might occasionally have a stall or two available for another pony; this breeder also offers pony leasing and pony training services.

6. Greymeadows Farm

Pony Head Close Up

Greymeadows Farm is a sport pony breeder located in Cutler. OH. Their ponies go from $5,000 (or less) to $10,000+. They are active on their Facebook page – contact them for a complete sales list of their animals.

7. The Willows Welsh Ponies

The Willows Welsh Ponies is a breeder of Section A Welsh mountain ponies. They currently have 3 stallions on their farm and offer a lifetime guarantee on their animals (they will welcome back any pony they sold that is no longer wanted by the owner due to injury, chronic illness, old age, unsuitability for the intended purpose, or for any other reason, with no questions asked). 

They sell most of their ponies through their Design-A-Foal program but might occasionally have a foal or mature pony available. Visit their website for a list of available animals.

8. Stargazey Farms 

Stargazey Farms breeds and sells Welsh ponies, Irish draughts, and Norwegian fjord horses. They are located in Jackson, OH, and strive to produce horses and ponies true to type with top-class personalities and athleticism capable of pursuing an array of disciplines. 

Stargazey Farms also offers stud services – you can visit their farm in person if interested in their stallion services, purchasing a horse or pony, or looking to get involved with their charitable work. Just make sure to make an appointment.

9. Hickory Run Farms 

Located in Alexandria, OH, Hickory Run Farms is a boarding, training, and lesson facility built in 2016. They sell horses and ponies – contact them directly about the available animals and prices.

10. Double R Farms

Double R Farms is a private family-owned and operated facility in Mount Sterling, OH. Together with miniature donkeys, they raise and sell ponies and horses. You will need to pay a non-refundable deposit to reserve an animal – visit their For Sale page and contact them directly about available ponies. 

Additional Listing Information

Are You Selling Ponies In Ohio And Aren’t Listed Here?

Contacts us here and we will add you to the list.

Interested In Buying Other Animals In Ohio? 

Here are:


And there you have it! 10 places with ponies for sale in Ohio (OH). 

Ponies can vary in price depending on their age, breed, and training level. But don’t worry, there are plenty of affordable options out there in Ohio! Remember to factor in some additional costs, like transportation and vet examinations. 

When choosing a pony breeder, take the time to do your research. Look for someone with a good reputation in the equine community and ask for references. Once you’ve found a pony you’re interested in, it’s important to have a veterinarian conduct a pre-purchase exam. Some ranches offer that option; you will most likely have to pay for it. 

If visiting in person, try spending some time with the pony before making your decision. Test ride it and observe its behavior both on the ground and under the saddle. This will help you make sure that you have a good rapport and that the pony is a good fit for you. 

We wish you luck in buying your next pet – feel free to send us a message if we’ve helped you find a proper one!

    Skip to content